As our player season reviews rolls on, you’ve probably read a lot about Quentin Grimes’ 2025-26 season if you’ve spent any time on this blog this offseason. He played well for the first two months of the season before struggling for the back half of the season.
Save for one game in Boston, his playoffs were just as frustrating. He shot 39% from the field in the postseason despite going 40% from three. Forgive us for hammering this point home, but after touting a “glut of guards” at the trade deadline, a struggling Grimes was the only playable guard off the bench in the playoffs.
The only question remains is should the Sixers entertain bringing Grimes back? Game 2 of their playoff series against the New York Knicks showed that their backcourt is not as gluttonous as originally thought. Tyrese Maxey only sat for a minute and a half in that game, and yet the six points the Sixers lost those minutes by ended up being the difference in the game.
As Grimes showed in Game 5 in Boston, he can hang on the floor defensively and can even be a plus defender against star-level players. It’s clearly something Nick Nurse prioritizes in a guard playing next to Maxey. It was a big reason Grimes was comfortably ahead of Jared McCain in the rotation, and why the Sixers felt they were choosing Grimes over McCain at the deadline.
The biggest flaw in Grimes’ game is what makes his return a hard sell, and that is scalability. For the second straight season, Grimes had his best stretch of the year cooking on his own while the top three players on the team were out due to injury or suspension.
He was just never able to find a rhythm offensively when guys came back and he had a smaller role. This was most evident in his three-point attempts per game decreasing throughout the season. He started the season taking 6.4 threes a game and finished the season averaging only five. He only took 3.2 threes a game in the postseason.
As it often does, the conversation on keeping Grimes or not boils down to price. The reported number of $15 million per year is way too steep a price for the Sixers to pay, given their limited resources. If the Sixers are able to stay under the luxury tax they’d have access to the full $15 million dollar non-taxpayer mid-level exception. If they go over the first but stay under the second apron, they’d get the $6.1 million taxpayer exception.
That’s a much more palatable number to bring Grimes back. At the same time, Grimes will probably be looking to make more money than that exception, which is less money than what the qualifying offer he signed to play on this past season.
The biggest factor in this will be how willing this new front office will be to go near the aprons for a team they admit is not a championship contender at the moment. It’s a problem without a clear and easy fix, but the Sixers do have some work to do to make their backcourt gluttonous once again.
